The Controversy of, and Holistic Therapies for ADHD

Posted on

As a faculty psychologist who began his profession over 30 years in the past as a secondary science instructor I’ve at all times relied on analysis and information to help my beliefs. And once I explored the character vs nurture (genetics vs surroundings) debate because it applies to psychological sickness I’ve discovered (based mostly on analysis and information) that over 75 p.c of psychological sickness is because of environmental components, not genetics. This is what I consider and located to be the case with ADHD (if the “dysfunction” exists in any respect!).

Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is taken into account the commonest childhood neurobehavioral dysfunction of school-aged kids at this time. And, it’s the most controversial dysfunction additionally. Controversial after we test past mainstream conventional Western (allopathic) analysis and therapy. As a faculty psychologist with over thirty years’ expertise working with college students and households from the pre-kindergarten age by grade twelve, I’ve not often seen “correct” analysis of the dysfunction. What I’ve seen are kids “drugged” so as to “do higher at school.” This present development in medicating and labeling our youngsters can have lifelong unfavorable results!

Today there are a lot of physicians, psychiatrists and psychologists that query whether or not such a dysfunction even exists. And, they refuse to suggest psycho-stimulate remedy for the “dysfunction’s” signs, however search various therapies.

According to the DSM-IV, kids with ADHD show problematic behaviors at dwelling and 80% are believed to show tutorial efficiency issues. Estimates vary between 4 to 12 p.c of college kids have the dysfunction. Children which are identified with ADHD normally are placed on psycho-stimulate remedy with what appears to be little concern of short-term or long-term unintended effects.

Of the 5 million kids at this time with ADHD over three million take Ritalin (methylphenidate) with typically solely cursory medical/skilled analysis of the dysfunction. The medical group seems to be extra concern with controlling the coed’s conduct with medication quite than attempting to find out a reason for the situation. However, there are a selection of theories at this time that tackle the trigger and therapy of the situation’s signs with out the usage of probably dangerous drugs.

Diagnosis of ADHD

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) calls ADHD the commonest childhood neurobehavioral dysfunction. Not surprisingly, the AAP questions the potential over-diagnosis of ADHD.

In their May, 2000 problem of Pediatrics the AAP requires stricter tips for major care physicians diagnosing ADHD in kids age six to 12 years-old. These tips embrace: utilizing the DSM-IV standards, with signs being current in two or extra settings, the signs adversely affecting the kid’s tutorial or social functioning for at the least six months, the evaluation ought to embrace info from mother and father in addition to classroom lecturers or different faculty professionals, and the analysis of ADHD must also embrace an evaluation for co-existing situations comparable to studying or language issues.

The AAP seems to be involved that far too many physicians will place a baby on psycho-stimulate remedy with little or no evaluation of the situation. Often they communicate solely to the mother and father or give the kid a fast in-office bodily earlier than writing a prescription for Ritalin.

The National Association of School Psychologists (NASP) of their textual content, Best Practices in School Psychology (1995), outlines particular standards kids should meet so as to be identified with ADHD. This standards not solely consists of DSM-IV tips however meets federal necessities for evaluating a baby to qualify for academic companies underneath the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA).

Therefore, faculty psychologists are sometimes confronted with the duty of reconciling confused communication amongst mother and father (who consider one thing just isn’t proper with their little one), faculty personnel (who’ve strict federal tips so as service college students with particular wants) and medical personnel (that label kids ADHD and prescribe drugs with none testing).

Have I seen this type of “appropriate” analysis for ADHD? Rarely, if ever! What normally occurs is {that a} guardian brings their little one to the household doctor, stating that the kid is having bother paying consideration at school and the doctor provides an on-the-spot analysis of ADHD, and writes a script for a trial of an ADHD remedy.

Causes of ADHD

The medical group seems to down play anyone deciding issue that might trigger ADHD, and would quite checklist a number of components which will contribute to the situation. Dr. Okay. S. Berger, in his guide, The Developing Person Through the Life Span (1998) states that present analysis lists components comparable to genetics, prenatal injury from teratogens, or postnatal injury, comparable to from lead poisoning or head trauma as the reason for ADHD.

Russell Barkley, Ph.D. creator of a number of books on ADHD comparable to Taking Charge of ADHD, (1995) cites current analysis indicating that the areas of the mind in kids with ADHD are shriveled when put next with kids with out the dysfunction. Possible causes for the discount could possibly be polygenetic in nature. Specifically genes that dictate the best way the mind makes use of a neurotransmitter referred to as the dopamine receptor are regarded as mutated in kids with ADHD. Other theories embrace prenatal alcohol consumption, fatty acid deficiency, defective glucose metabolism, and thyroid abnormalities as potential causes of ADHD.

David Stein, Ph.D. questions if ADHD is a medical dysfunction in any respect. He states that there’s little scientific proof to help that it’s a medical situation. Dr. Stein means that the surroundings a baby is introduced up in is the first motive for ADHD conduct. In his guide, Ritalin Is Not The Answer (1999), he contends lack of self-discipline within the dwelling or within the classroom is the principle reason for ADHD. He believes by setting constant boundaries with conduct management interventions, ADHD signs could be eradicated.

Sugar seems to be extremely controversial relating to its impact on kids and the opportunity of it inflicting ADHD. Depending on which examine you learn, you could be totally confused as to its relation to kids’s conduct. Dr. William Crook, a pediatrician whom had been treating hyperactive kids for twenty-five years, studies in a 5 12 months examine, the place he interview mother and father of 182 hyperactive kids and located the nice majority of the youngsters had been adversely affected by their weight-reduction plan. He discovered their hyperactivity was undoubtedly associated to particular meals they consumed, the worst offender being sugar.

Another examine by the New York Institute of Child Development in New York City concerned 265 hyperactive kids. They discovered that 74 p.c of the youngsters had an lack of ability to correctly digest and assimilate sugar and different refined carbohydrates. A examine carried out by the National Institute of Mental Health confirmed that the speed at which the mind makes use of glucose, its most important power supply, is decrease with topics with ADHD than with topics with out ADHD.

Mary Block, M.D., in her guide, No More Ritalin, Treating ADHD Without Drugs (1996) explains how reactive hypoglycemia and adrenaline ranges are associated. Dr. Block states when we’ve too little glucose in our physique (blood sugar) the physique releases a backup reserve referred to as epinephrine or adrenaline. Adrenaline is a hormone that provides the physique an power surge. The physique goes into hypoglycemia (low blood sugar) by both not consuming sufficient or paradoxically by consuming an excessive amount of sugar. People with reactive hypoglycemia could have a metabolism drawback that causes the over secretion of adrenaline. Dr. Block cites a Yale examine that examined the consequences of sugar on blood glucose and adrenaline ranges. The examine confirmed the adrenaline ranges of kids had been ten occasions greater than regular as much as 5 hours after ingesting the sugar. She explains that many research that present a poor relationship between sugar consumption and conduct are normally flawed and poorly carried out. She additionally makes the purpose if any medical professionals questions the impact sugar has on conduct they need to speak to a guardian or instructor round Halloween.

In the 1970’s Ben Feingold, M.D., developed one of many first pure approaches to treating hyperactivity. He was a pediatrician who taught at Northwestern University and a pioneer within the fields of allergy and immunology. He additionally served as Chief of Allergies on the Kaiser Permanente Medical Center in San Francisco.

According to Dr. Feingold many hyperactive kids are delicate to naturally occurring salicylates and phenolic compounds. Salicylates are used as meals preservatives and within the manufacturing of aspirin. Dr. Feingold decided that meals components induce hyperactivity after researching over 1,200 circumstances the place components had been linked to conduct issues. Dr. Feingold believes that salicylates, synthetic colours, and synthetic flavors within the weight-reduction plan are chargeable for hyperactivity in kids.

Dr. Weintraub studies way back to 1940 there have been studies of sensitivities to meals dyes, aspirin, and naturally occurring salicylate substances present in fruit and veggies. Dr. Weintraub cites different research in help of Dr. Feingold’s idea. A examine revealed in Lancet (1985) discovered that 82 p.c of a big group of hyperactive kids responded positively to a hypoallergenic elimination weight-reduction plan. While on the weight-reduction plan lots of the kids’s conduct turned regular. The mostly upsetting substances had been synthetic meals colours and preservatives.

Dr. Carl Pfeiffer M.D. recommends a pure weight-reduction plan for hyperactive kids based mostly on the assumption that meals components, synthetic colours, flavors and preservatives causes hyperactivity. Another examine in help of Dr. Feingold’s theories, was a examine of 76 hyperactive kids. When positioned on a restricted weight-reduction plan devoid of components 62 of the youngsters improved and 21 realized regular conduct.

Dr. Weintraub discusses a current examine carried out on the Royal Children’s Hospital, University of Melbourne, Australia of 200 hyperactive kids. In a six week trial, the youngsters had been positioned on a weight-reduction plan freed from all artificial meals. The mother and father of 150 kids reported important behavioral enhancements, nonetheless, they famous when synthetic colours had been added again into their diets their conduct worsened. The extra meals coloring they consumed, the longer the undesirable conduct lasted.

A 1994 examine on the North Shore Hospital-Cornell Medical Center discovered that by eliminating reactive meals comparable to these with meals components and synthetic colours the ADHD signs of irritability, restlessness, sleep disturbances and different unfavorable behaviors had been lowered.

By utilizing PET scans of the mind scientists are capable of visually observe the quantity of glucose sure areas of the mind makes use of. In analyzing the brains of individuals with ADHD, there are specific areas of the mind that present decreased use of glucose and diminished mind metabolism. Scientists are at present trying to find the reason for this decreased glucose metabolism in folks with ADHD.

Another noticed neurodevelopment dysfunction that results in ADHD signs has been related to fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS). FAS is attributable to over consumption of alcohol throughout being pregnant, and kids with FAS are characterised with low delivery weight, an impaired mind, and sure bodily defects. Children born with FAS present the identical hyperactivity, low impulse management, and lack of ability to concentrate as these kids identified with ADHD.

A wide range of current observations have led investigators to conclude there’s a relationship between thyroid dysfunction and ADHD. It has been noticed that as much as 70 p.c of all kids with a situation often known as “generalized thyroid resistance” additionally reveal ADHD signs. Patients with thyroid resistance endure from altered glucose uptake by cells, a characteristic that we now know impairs mind metabolism. Altered glucose uptake is linked to ADHD if that diminished mind exercise occurs to be within the mind areas chargeable for our capability to concentrate and management our conduct.

Thyroid dysfunction could also be attributable to artificial chemical compounds like PCBs, phenols, and extreme histamines. A fatty acid deficiency can be associated to thyroid dysfunction. A big portion of the mind consists of fat, referred to as phospholipids which are derived from important fatty acids. A variety of research have recognized an important fatty acid (EFA) deficiency in lots of hyperactive kids. For instance, a 1995 examine revealed in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition confirmed a correlation between low omega-3 blood ranges and ADHD in younger boys. EFAs play necessary roles in neurotransmitter perform in communication of neurotransmitters and in correct nerve cell growth.

Peter Breggin, MD, is a psychiatrist that has been specializing in ADHD therapy for over 30 years. In his books, Talking Back to Ritalin, (2001), and The Ritalin Fact Book, What Your Doctor Won’t Tell You about Stimulant Drugs, (2002) he contends that ADHD is a dysfunction that was fabricated by the pharmaceutical firms so as to promote their medication. He refutes the medical proof that ADHD is a neurological dysfunction by stating that the analysis that confirmed lowered consideration facilities in ADHD kids was flawed.

At the National Institute of Mental Health’s Conference on ADHD (1998) Dr. Breggin was invited to talk and was one of many few critics of typical psycho-stimulate remedy for ADHD. At that convention he identified that the research on mind atrophy of ADHD kids concerned kids that had already been on psycho-stimulate remedy. And, that earlier research have proven that psycho-stimulate drugs in actual fact, causes mind atrophy. That convention, that had thirty nationwide consultants on ADHD concluded that there’s at present no conclusive proof that implies that ADHD is a medical dysfunction. In his books, Dr. Breggin presents medical research that present that there are little long-term academic advantages in utilizing psycho-stimulates. And, he elaborates on the numerous important dangerous results of the medication. Dr. Breggin has additionally been concerned a number of particular person and class-action fits as an skilled witness towards the pharmaceutical firms over wrongful deaths and in poor health results from the medication prescribed for ADHD.

Traditional Treatment:

Traditional Western drugs (Allopathic) therapy for ADHD constant primarily of prescribing psycho-stimulants to regulate the kid’s conduct. Physicians prescribe a psycho-stimulant like Ritalin, Concerta or Adderall normally beginning in a small dose (5 or 10 mg) and enhance it month-to-month based mostly on a discount of the ADHD signs. Side-effects are monitored and drugs are sometimes switched if side-effects are too extreme or if there isn’t any noticeable distinction within the kid’s conduct.

The most typical remedy for ADHD is Ritalin (Methylphenidate hydrochloride). Or one other model identify drug like Concerta which is similar chemical make-up. This drug acts a central nervous system stimulate, that additionally will increase manufacturing of a neuro-transmitter (dopamine), the a lot the identical approach as cocaine does. Side results can vary from insomnia, nervousness, lack of urge for food, stomach ache, weight reduction, abnormally quick heartbeat, blood stress adjustments, dizziness, drowsiness, fever, hair loss, headache, hives, joint ache, nausea, palpitations, pores and skin irritation, pores and skin rash, Tourette’s syndrome, to psychotic reactions.

Another widespread remedy for ADHD is Adderall and Adderall XR (d-amphetamine and amphetamine combination). This drug blocks the reuptake of neurotransmitters, thereby prolonging their actions and slows down metabolism. Common unintended effects may embrace: Irritability, nervousness, insomnia, euphoria, dry mouth, fast heartbeat, dizziness, lowered alertness, blurred imaginative and prescient, headache, diarrhea or constipation, urge for food loss, nausea, weight reduction, seizures, and irregular heartbeat. Interestingly, the drug was taken off the market in Canada due Adderall’s connection to coronary heart assaults in kids. However, the FDA solely issued a “warning” within the U.S.

Additional drugs may be prescribed like Trazadone, to assist the kid sleep at evening, or an anti-anxiety remedy in the event that they develop twitches or tics (Paxil, Wellbutrin, Klonopin). Occasionally the ups and downs of the drugs causes the kid to hallucinate or have “temper swings” and they’re then identified with Bipolar Disorder (turning into a highly regarded childhood analysis) and anti-psychotic remedy is prescribed (like Depakote or Zyprexa).

Naturopathic Treatment:

There are many components are main numerous medical doctors to query the analysis of ADHD. First there may be the numerous side-effects of the drugs prescribed to kids. Then there may be the growing proof of little long-term enchancment academically of scholars, and there may be the query of the standards that truly diagnoses the ADHD.

When trying into the DSM-IV standards for ADHD many are struck with the belief that 9 out of 10 kids could possibly be identified with the “dysfunction”. It seems that many regular childhood behaviors like: “fails to complete schoolwork or chores,” “usually dislikes and avoids homework!” or, “has problem awaiting flip,” are used to find out if a baby has ADHD. Then there may be the belief that psycho-stimulates don’t remedy the reason for the behaviors, however merely provide the affected person with a bandage (life-long?) for the dysfunction. However, many naturopathic or various therapies could in actual fact remedy the “dysfunction.”

A current medical examine that measured the effectiveness of dietary interventions in comparison with conventional psycho-stimulant therapy. In Alternative Medicine Review (2003 Aug; 8(3):319-30) a examine reported: “These findings help the effectiveness of meals complement therapy in bettering consideration and self-control in kids with ADHD and recommend meals complement therapy of ADHD could also be of equal efficacy to Ritalin therapy.”

Since Dr. Feingold pioneered his theories of diet-related causes for hyperactive conduct there have been a number of variations in help of a extra pure weight-reduction plan as a remedy. Dr. Feingold’s weight-reduction plan has been referred to as an elimination weight-reduction plan because of the course of he recommends of first eliminating all meals that comprise pure and artificial salicylates. Natural salicylates embrace fruit and veggies comparable to almonds, apples, apricots, berries, cherries, grapes, raisins, oranges, peaches, plums, prunes, strawberries, pickles, tomatoes, cucumbers and vinegar.

Synthetic salicylates embrace all meals that comprise synthetic colours and synthetic flavors, comparable to benzoic acid, BHA, BHT, MSG, butylene glycol, potassium bisulfate, potassium and sodium nitrate, sulfites, and tartrazines. Once a baby’s conduct is normalized, which can take 4 to 6 weeks, meals gadgets could slowly reintroduced into their weight-reduction plan and monitored for his or her impact on the kid’s conduct.

Frank Lawlis, Ph.D. in his guide The ADD Answer: How to Help Your Child Now, expands Dr. Feingold’s weight-reduction plan and offers particular weight-reduction plan suggestions for the kid with ADHD. He recommends all the household comply with such a weight-reduction plan to offer the kid help, because the weight-reduction plan could be very restrictive (see desk 4-2). Dr. Lawlis states that meals which have a unfavorable influence on kids’s well being embrace: synthetic colours and preservatives, processed milk and milk merchandise, wheat merchandise (not entire grains), sugar, oranges, grapefruits, eggs, and MSG. He additionally recommends a weight-reduction plan wealthy in calcium, magnesium, zinc (necessary in correct neurotransmitter perform), nutritional vitamins C and B6 (necessary in immune system and metabolism perform), B12 (will increase power, lessens anxiousness, will increase focus), fish oil (accommodates DHA necessary in mind well being), protein (stimulates psychological alertness), pycnogenol or grape seed extract (two herbs that enhance blood stream within the mind) and probiotic (helps restore wholesome micro organism within the intestines).

Dr. Lawlis warns that drugs used for ADHD could cause extreme side-effects comparable to psychosis, together with manic and schizophrenic episodes. Often when such side-effects happen physicians don’t cease medicating, they prescribe extra medication, diagnosing the kid with despair or delinquent persona dysfunction, they usually deal with the kid with antidepressants, temper stabilizers or narcoleptics. It just isn’t uncommon for kids to be taking as many as 5 totally different drugs that trigger a number of side-effects. He states, “Meds upon meds is insanity upon insanity.”

Many researchers describe a pure remedy of elevated protein within the weight-reduction plan to extend serotonin, which has a chilled impact on kids with hyperactivity. Also really useful are giant quantities of B nutritional vitamins, with emphasis on B6 (pyridoxine), vitamin C, and important fatty acids (EFA’s).

M. Salaman creator of Foods That Heal (1989) cites analysis that used excessive doses of vitamin B6 (pyridoxine) to regulate hyperactivity. In the examine, excessive doses of B6 got to hyperactive kids for seven weeks adopted by seven weeks of Ritalin, and 7 weeks of a placebo. The excessive dose of B6 proved to be the simplest therapy, the place it raised the blood serotonin degree and Ritalin didn’t. Dr. Salaman additionally recommends EFA supplementation of 1,000 to 1,500 mg capsules of night primrose within the morning and night. She notes some kids reply higher if the night primrose oil is rubbed into their pores and skin, as very often kids with hyperactivity could have poor intestinal tract absorption.

In Summary:

Current analysis does help pure therapy for ADHD, a dysfunction that’s thought-about an unnatural response to environmental components (if in actual fact such a dysfunction exists). There seems to be substantial proof to help dietary components that trigger ADHD behaviors of hyperactivity and inattention, are associated to sugar consumption, response to meals components, defective glucose metabolism (sugar consumption), and fatty acid deficiency. Parents do in actual fact have a alternative in relation to therapy for his or her kids. They not have to put their little one on probably dangerous psycho-stimulate drugs. Or, probably threat a lifelong sample of drug dependence for his or her kids, in addition to “labeling” them with a dysfunction that may have lifelong implications of them believing that there’s something flawed with them.

Medications comparable to Ritalin, Adderall, Concerta, Strattera, Cylert, Dexedrine, Tofranil, and Norpramin have unintended effects that vary from delicate (dry mouth, nausea, complications, dizziness, constipation, irritability) to critical (anorexia, insomnia, weight reduction, despair, palpitations, blurred imaginative and prescient, hypertension), to very critical (suppressed progress, liver injury, Tourette’s syndrome, psychosis, drug dependence).

The pure method to therapy of ADHD could require extra effort and time by the household when limiting their kid’s weight-reduction plan, however the advantages of the method are nice. The reason for the kid’s conduct can have been uncovered and never simply covered-up by treating the signs with dangerous medication.

Current analysis involving the usage of multi-vitamin and multi-mineral dietary supplements, herbs and eliminating toxins within the weight-reduction plan comparable to meals colorings, components and heavy metals, all seem to have a dramatic impact on a decreasing a baby’s ADHD signs with out dangerous facet impact.

Holistic Mental Health for ADHD

Specific Recommendations:

Based on this analysis, therapy of ADHD ought to progress from the least dangerous plan of action. Families ought to attempt to uncover the reason for the situation, enabling therapy with out dangerous medication. Causes of ADHD that may be handled with out psycho-stimulate drugs embrace meals allergic reactions, nutrient deficiencies, and weight-reduction plan restriction intervention. Recommended course of therapy:

• An analysis with a naturopathic doctor to find out if a meals allergy exists and a dietary analysis to find out if a nutrient deficiency exists.

• Eliminate all processed meals that comprise synthetic components comparable to aspartame, benzoic acid, BHA, BHT, MSG, butylene glycol, potassium bisulfate, potassium and sodium nitrate, sulfites, and tartrazines from the weight-reduction plan.

• Eliminate pure salicylates comparable to almonds, apples, apricots, berries, cherries, grapes, raisins, oranges, peaches, plums, prunes, strawberries, pickles, tomatoes, cucumbers and vinegar from the weight-reduction plan.

• Add a vitamin/mineral complement day by day, with further B-complex (120 to 150 mg, per day), vitamin C (1,000 to 2,000 mg, per day), calcium (1,000 to 1,500 mg, per day), magnesium (300 to 500 mg, per day), zinc (20 to 30 mg, per day) and selenium (100 to 200 mcg, per day), and an EFA complement containing omega-3 EFAs comparable to in EPA fish oil capsules, or take night primrose oil (2,000 to three,000 mg, per day in two doses).

• Calming herbs comparable to St. John’s wort, valerian or skullcap could be tried to scale back signs of hyperactivity and irritability.

Suggested Further Reading:

P. R. Breggin. Talking Back to Ritalin, (Cambridge, MA: Perseus Publishing. 2001).

M. A. Block. No More Ritalin: Treating ADHD Without Drugs, (New York, NY: Kensington Publishing Corp. 1996).

B. F. Feingold. Why Your Child Is Hyperactive. (New York, NY: Random House, 1975).

F. Lawlis. The ADD Answer. (New York, NY: The Penguin Group. 2004).

D. S. Nambudripad. Say Good-bye To ADD and ADHD. (Buena park, CA: Delta Publishing Co. 1999).

D. B. Stein. Ritalin Is Not The Answer. (San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishers, 1999).

*Article reprinted from: Holistic Mental Health-Revised (IUniverse, Bloomington, IN., 2009). by Dave DiSano, Ph.D.

Leave a Reply